Knowledge / Tax planning
Tax planning: status first, rates second
US broker tax rules depend on residency, account type, and holding period. Non-residents usually face dividend withholding, and capital gains rules differ; confirm your status before planning trades and withdrawals.
Status drives the rules
US citizens and green-card holders report worldwide income; non-residents are usually taxed on US-source income and certify status on W-8BEN. A change of status affects withholding and filing.
| Status | Form | Focus |
|---|---|---|
| US citizen | W-9 | Worldwide income |
| Green card | W-9 | Worldwide income |
| Non-resident | W-8BEN | US-source income |
| Entity | W-8BEN-E | Entity status |
Dividends and capital gains
Non-resident US dividends are generally withheld at 30%, though treaty rates can be lower; capital gains are generally exempt, with exceptions such as real estate. For US residents, short- and long-term gains are taxed differently.
| Item | Non-resident | Resident |
|---|---|---|
| Dividends | 30% withholding | By bracket |
| Capital gains | Generally exempt | Short or long |
| Interest | Generally exempt | By income |
| Estate tax | US assets possible | Worldwide assets |
Tax timing of retirement accounts
Traditional 401(k) and IRA defer tax at contribution and tax withdrawals; Roth taxes contributions and allows tax-free qualified withdrawals. Taxable accounts are taxed on realised gains each year.
| Account | Contribution | Withdrawal |
|---|---|---|
| Traditional 401(k) | Pre-tax | Taxed |
| Traditional IRA | Often pre-tax | Taxed |
| Roth IRA | After-tax | Qualified tax-free |
| Taxable | No limit | Capital gains |
A USD 10,000 example
Hold USD 10,000 of a 2% dividend stock; annual dividends are USD 200, or USD 140 after 30% withholding. Sell for a USD 1,000 gain and a non-resident is generally exempt from US capital gains tax, but local filing may still apply.
After-tax return is the return you keep.
Do not treat withholding as the whole cost.
Tax-loss harvesting
Selling losers can offset gains, but watch the wash-sale rule: buying a substantially identical security within 30 days can disallow the loss.
Check the rules first; do not let tax drive a bad investment decision.
Records and filing
Keep confirmations, statements, and dividend records; brokers usually issue annual tax forms. Non-residents may need to file on US-source income and report foreign assets at home.
Rules vary by country; consult a tax professional if needed.
Three common errors
Ignoring withholding
Overstated returns.
Expired forms
Top rate returns.
Ignoring home filing
Compliance risk.
Estate tax and cross-border holdings
US assets held by non-residents may be subject to US estate tax, with thresholds and rules that differ from residents; cross-border structures are complex and worth planning early.
Asset type and ownership structure change the outcome.
Three common errors
Assuming permanent exemption
Rules change.
Ignoring treaties
Paying too much withholding.
No records
Cannot prove cost.
Five common questions
What is non-resident dividend tax?
Usually 30%, lower under a tax treaty.
Are capital gains taxed?
Generally exempt for non-residents, with exceptions and local rules.
What if W-8BEN expires?
Withholding may revert to the top rate; resubmit the form.
What is a wash sale?
Buying a substantially identical security within 30 days can disallow the loss.
Do I need a US tax ID?
Depends on status and filing; follow broker and tax rules.
Sources: E*TRADE tax and forms pages, IRS public materials, checked 2026-11. Not tax advice. Independent guide, not affiliated with E*TRADE.