Investing / ETFs
ETFs: beyond zero commission, look at expenses and tracking
E*TRADE charges USD 0 online commission on US-listed ETFs, but ETFs carry expense ratios, spreads, and tracking error. Choosing an ETF means choosing exposure, cost, and structure.
What an ETF is
An ETF trades on an exchange and holds a basket of assets, with live prices. It trades like a stock, but the underlying may be an index, bonds, commodities, or a theme.
| Type | Exposure | Risk |
|---|---|---|
| Broad equity | Market | Market risk |
| Sector/theme | Specific segment | Concentration |
| Bond | Rates and credit | Rate risk |
| Commodity | Commodity prices | Futures structure |
Costs: three layers
First, commission (USD 0 if eligible); second, the expense ratio; third, spreads and tracking error. For long holding periods, the expense ratio matters most.
| Layer | Example | Impact |
|---|---|---|
| Commission | USD 0 | Per trade |
| Expense ratio | 0.03%–0.75% | Annual |
| Spread | Liquidity-dependent | Per trade |
| Tracking error | Product-dependent | Long term |
Five questions before buying
What does it track? What does it cost? How large is it? How liquid is it? How is it taxed? If you cannot answer, do not buy.
| Question | Why | Common trap |
|---|---|---|
| Index tracked | Defines exposure | Name vs content |
| Expense ratio | Long-term cost | Looking only at commission |
| Size | Durability | Too small may close |
| Liquidity | Spread | Wide spreads |
| Tax | After-tax return | Ignoring withholding |
Tax: dividends and gains
Non-US residents generally face 30% withholding on US ETF dividends; capital gains are generally not withheld by the US but are reportable locally.
Dividends
May be withheld; similar to single stocks.
Capital gains
Reportable where you reside.
Estate tax
US assets may be involved; check first.
Three common errors
Looking only at zero commission
Expenses and spreads can be higher.
Buying overlapping ETFs
Looks diversified but overlaps.
Ignoring tax
Gross returns overstate results.
A USD 50,000 ETF example
Example: USD 35,000 US broad-market ETF, USD 10,000 global ETF, USD 5,000 bond ETF. This is not advice; it shows how three funds can build a core allocation.
Proportions depend on goals, time, and risk capacity; write them down before buying.
Three funds are usually enough; more adds management and overlap.
Trading: spreads and sessions
ETFs trade on exchanges; liquid products have narrower spreads, while the open and close can be wider. Use limit orders to control price.
Avoid market orders in the first minutes; check spreads and volume first.
Tax and dividends
Non-US residents generally face 30% withholding on US ETF dividends; capital gains are reportable where you reside. After-tax return is what you keep.
On USD 1,000 of dividends at 30% withholding, net is USD 700.
Five common questions
Is ETF trading commission-free?
Eligible US-listed ETFs are USD 0 online; regulatory fees and spreads still apply.
How do expense ratios affect returns?
They are deducted from fund assets annually; the gap grows over time.
Can an ETF close?
Small funds may close; prefer larger, established products.
ETF or mutual fund?
ETFs trade live and usually cost less; funds are bought at NAV.
Are there tax issues for non-residents?
Dividends may be withheld; check your residence rules.
Sources: E*TRADE ETF and pricing pages, checked 2026-11. Examples only. Independent guide, not affiliated with E*TRADE.