Morgan Stanley · US broker · Independent guideNon-official noticeOpen an account
ETE*TRADE GuideIndependent · US investing
Account TypesInvestment ChoicesTradingKnowledgeOpen an account

Accounts / Retirement

Retirement: Traditional versus Roth IRA

E*TRADE offers Traditional and Roth IRAs. Traditional may be pre-tax with taxable withdrawals; Roth is after-tax with qualified tax-free withdrawals. Both require US tax status and earned income.

Comparing the two IRAs

Traditional may reduce current taxable income; Roth taxes now and allows qualified tax-free withdrawals. The choice depends on current versus future tax rates.

Table 1: IRA comparison
ItemTraditionalRoth
ContributionMay be pre-taxAfter-tax
WithdrawalTaxableQualified tax-free
Age limitYesNo
FitsHigher current rateLower current rate

Contributions and limits

Limits depend on the year and age; age 50+ usually allows catch-up. Contributions need earned income and cannot exceed it.

Table 2: Contribution checks
ItemWatchCommon issue
Annual limitIRSExcess contribution
Catch-upAge 50+Not reported
IncomeEarned income requiredInvestment income only
Roth eligibilityIncome-basedAbove the limit

Withdrawals and penalties

Early Traditional withdrawals may face a 10% penalty plus income tax; Roth qualified withdrawals are tax-free, but the five-year rule and age 59½ matter.

Table 3: Withdrawal rules
CaseTraditionalRoth
After 59½TaxableQualified tax-free
EarlyTax + penaltyMay be restricted
ExceptionsIRS rulesIRS rules
Do not use a retirement account as an emergency fund; the tax and penalty cost is high.

Three common errors

Excess contributions

Above the annual limit; correct and possibly pay a penalty.

Ignoring income limits

Roth has income thresholds; excess must be handled.

Early withdrawals

Tax and penalties eat returns.

Tax example: USD 10,000 contribution

At a 24% marginal rate, a Traditional contribution may reduce current tax by about USD 2,400; Roth taxes now but qualified withdrawals are tax-free. Actual results depend on you.

Do not look only at current tax savings; consider future withdrawal rates.

If you expect a lower retirement rate, Traditional may help more.

Transfers and consolidation

Moving retirement assets may use ACATS or trustee-to-trustee transfer; confirm fees, tax, and timing to avoid a taxable event.

Direct transfers are usually safer than withdrawing and redepositing.

How to choose

High current rate and lower expected retirement rate favour Traditional; low current rate and tax-free withdrawals favour Roth.

If unsure, contribute to both, but stay within the combined limit.

Five common questions

Traditional or Roth?

Compare current and future tax rates; Traditional may suit a higher current rate.

Can I have both IRAs?

Yes, but the contribution limit is combined.

Can I contribute without income?

Usually earned income is required; follow IRS rules.

Is there an early withdrawal penalty?

Usually 10% plus income tax; exceptions follow IRS rules.

Can non-residents open an IRA?

Usually US tax status and earned income are required.

Sources: E*TRADE retirement pages and IRS public materials, checked 2026-11. Rules follow official terms. Review beneficiaries after major life changes and keep contribution records for tax filing, and check the rules each year, because limits change. Independent guide, not affiliated with E*TRADE.